Fostoria American Glass
compared to Jobling 2077 & other look-alikes

Fostoria American glass

Fostoria American and Jobling 2077 patterns are very similar, as Emily Seate, co-author of the book "Fostoria Stemware" pointed out. There has been some confusion which I hope this short piece helps to sort it out.

John Bell, a glass specialist from the North East of England (the home of Joblings) has helped us by providing a photograph of his Jobling's bowl and many other people have contributed to the information now on this page.

The English company James A. Joblings & Co Ltd., produced a "3-handled salad bowl" and a "3-handled small bowl" in a very similar "icecube" pattern to Fostoria "American". This was part of an experiment in expensive quality pressed glass that Jobling's introduced in the mid-1930's, but discontinued in 1939 because the depression and the Second World War put an end to production.

The Jobling's catalogue form the mid 1930's shows only these two shapes in this pattern, and only in this colour (jade). However, an earlier catalogue shows these two three-handled bowls and in addition a large jug and small jug (each with one handle) and tumbler and low sugar bowl both without handles. There is a flint glass version and I have seen a deep turquoise version in John Bell's shop in the North East of England. These were probably made before the 1930s. Below is a photograph of the turquoise bowl (left) belonging to John Bell and my clear glass set with one jade bowl (right).


The Jobling's 2077 pattern is easy to distinguish from Fostoria American and other look-alikes because it always has a very large star on the side. With the large 3-handled bowls, the star is behind the handles. With the other shapes, it is in the centre of the side. It is shown most clearly in the catalogue picture below on the left, which shows the jugs in this pattern.


The plain "icecubes" pattern (without the Jobling's star) was known in England as "Georgian" and was imported in large quantities by Charles Pratt's National Glass Company (which had showrooms in Charterhouse Street, London) along with another popular design "Chippendale" (patented in the USA in 1907). In 1931 the British Government introduced a 50% import duty on glass, and at that time the moulds for popular designs from overseas were bought and imported so that the glass could be made in Britain.

We know that the moulds for the Czechoslovakian design known as "Jacobean" were imported around 1931, and British firms then made that design, notably Davidsons. The moulds for "Chippendale" were imported from the USA and made at Davidsons. So it would not be surprising to find that the moulds for "Georgian" were also imported and the glass made in England during the 1930's. Davidson's did advertise a design they called "Georgian" at that time, but I have not so far found a picture of that design. The picture below shows two English versions of the ice cube design. On the left is a small Jobling 2077 bowl in jade, and on the right a sugar bowl which is marked on the inside "Made in England" in jade glass typical of Davidson's. This is probably an example of Davidson's "Georgian" pattern.

Bagley's of Knottingley, in Yorkshire, made an icecubes pattern between 1931 and the end of 1939. They called it "Honeycomb" and they made a two-handled sugar bowl, cream jug, square lidded honey pot, dish and butter dish in this design. This design is easily confused with the Fostoria American pattern. If you have the two together (Fostoria and Bagley) then it can be distuinguished because I am told the Bagley Honeycomb pattern has a smaller cube than the Fostoria American.

Icecube Patterns in the USA

The Fostoria Glass Company Inc. of Moundsville, West Virginia, was the main USA producer of the icecube pattern. They introduced their pattern "2056 American" in 1915 and continued to produce it until their glassworks was closed in 1986. Over the years they made a very wide range of items in their "American" pattern. Whole books have been written just on this one pattern (see below). The quality of the glass was high and the icecube pattern clearly defined. It is very popular with glass collectors today.

Indiana Glass produced an icecube pattern which is not so easy to distinguish from Fostoria. This glassworks acquired the Fostoria molds when their parent company, Lancaster Colony Corporation, bought Fostoria Glass in 1985.

The 1982 and 1983 Indiana Glass catalogs show a pattern called "Whitehall" beverageware (footed tumbers) and apart from the fact that the foot is attached straight on the bowl (not even a short stem) the pattern is very similar to the American pattern "Footed Tumbler" shown in the 1982 Fostoria catalog. But the difference in the stems does make it possible to distinguish the Indiana tumblers from the Fostoria ones.

However the 1988-89 Indiana Glass catalog features a pattern called "American Whitehall" which was offered in 45 different items and from the photographs and from information reported elsewhere, these were made from the same molds as the Fostoria American pattern, and appear to have been identical. A few were offered in blue, a few in amber, but most were offered in Crystal. Indiana Glass was only marked with labels, which came off easily. So American Whitehall would be very easy to confuse with Fostoria's American.

Lancaster Colony Corp. stopped making lead-crystal glass around 1992, and changed the glass of some patterns from lead crystal to non-lead glass. So if the Indiana Glass American Whitehall pattern was offered in lead crystal originally, this would have changed in 1992.

JeannetteGlass Company produced a pattern known as "Cube" or "Cubist" between 1929 and 1933. It is a depression glass product, not as high quality as Fostoria American. It was made in several colors (pink, green, amber, blue, yellow, white, dark blue, and crystal) and in a wide range of items. Some of the items are similar in shape to the Fostoria American range. The cubes are not as sharply defined as the Fostoria pieces.


If you are looking for something in the Fostoria American pattern or any of the others mentioned on this page, you can usually find a good selection on offer on ebay. Click here see Fostoria glass currently for sale on ebay. Click here see Jeannette glass currently for sale on ebay. Click here see Bagley glass currently for sale on ebay. and click here see Jobling glass currently for sale on ebay.



The items below are for sale right now on eBay - we thought you would like to see these examples.




Here are some books with more information on Fostoria glass that you may find helpful. Click on any book cover on this page to read more about a particular book, including author, date of publication, publishers, price and any available discounts for buying on-line.

Ems Fostoria book Fostoria tableware book Fostoria tableware book 2
Bones Fostoria book Fostoria glass book Fostoria pressed glass book
Navarre Fostoria book Fostoria table glass book 20th Century glass book
Fostoria American Line book Fostoria book Seligson Glass book





New Zealand Glass book
INFORMATION about New Zealand Glass !
Including many original catalog pictures and dozens of photographs.
NOW available - this is the first paperback edition of the book
and it covers many contemporary New Zealand glass artists as well as
the history of glass in New Zealand, Crown Crystal Glass and New Zealand bottles.

Price US$29.90 plus pp.




Bagley glass

INFORMATION about Bagley Glass!

The first edition of this book sold out in a few months. The 2nd Edition is now available and has received a rave response - more information, more and better pictures, new items identified as Bagley for the first time, a helpful index, and more compehensive coverage; - and even better news - the price is lower! This book is a truly comprehensive guide to help you identify Bagley Glass. Click on the picture for more details.
2nd Edition book US$33.90 plus pp.



Glass Museum Articles on Glass





Looking for information? You can search the whole amazon.com site from here:

 Amazon.com logo
Enter keywords...







If you have any questions about glass that you think we can help with, please ask at the Glass Club Message Board.
And special thanks to all of you who share your knowledge by answering questions on the Message Board.



The Last Word:
Don't forget to look at your kind of glass in Angela's Designer Glass Searches - save time
and don't miss an opportunity even when you are busy! - glass - CLICK HERE



Copyright © 1997 - 2012 Angela M. Bowey.
Web site designed by: Angela M. Bowey.

No material from this website may be copied or reproduced without written permission from Angela M. Bowey. Full acknowledgement of the author and Glass Museum URL MUST be included, and copying any pictures is expressly forbidden. Please respect our copyright.
URL to this page:
http://www.theglassmuseum.com/icecube.htm